Friday, January 23, 2009

Canadian Pension Funds suffered worst losses on record in 2008: What are the IFRS accounting implications?

So what's this got to do with financial reporting under IFRS? Read on.

According to a report this morning by RBC Dexia Canadian Pension Funds suffered the worst losses on record in 2008. You would have to go back to the Depression perhaps for comparable data. RBC Dexia note that prior to the 1960s information is spotty. In the total year the drop was 15.9 percent (compared with 12.7 percent in 1974! - that was still bad though). The drop in value was seven percent in the last quarter alone.

Watson Wyatt reported earlier this month that the ratio of a "typical"pension plan's solvency valuation ratio of assets to liabilities fell from 96 percent last January to 69 percent at year end.

The federal government and provinces have promised relief by lengthening funding periods. We may have more relief in next week's federal budget (especially for people with defined contribution plans such as RSPs).

Focus on funding and cash requirements. What about financial reporting and disclosure? How will you be affected when IFRS is adopted? Did you know that the IASB is planning to eliminate smoothing of actuarial losses by 2011. For you techies it means the elimination of the "corridor" method for accounting purposes. (We have it as an available option in Canada under Handbook Section 3461 but it is applied differently from IFRS methodology. Please refer to the IFRS Canada Differences Memo on the CICA website). There may be relief on what is charged to net income but that has not been decided.

Very little has been written about pension accounting and IFRS as a separate topic. There is a chapter on the issues in iGAAP:IFRS for Canada that is very extensive. There seems to have been little public debate in Canada. Recently Ernst and Young has issued a two page memorandum that discusses some of the issues in Canadian conversions related to applying IFRS pension rules of measurement and disclosure. As usual they extend beyond accounting. Please keep your eye on the road!

My advice is to get looking at it now an work with your actuary. Burying your head in the sand like an Ostrich will not help. (Yes I know this Ostrich thing is a myth - but you know what I mean).

I will be presenting a workshop on pension costs and pension plans next Wednesday at the IQPC seminar in Toronto. Hold on to your hats! Sorry a not so transparent plug for my blog on hats called Many Hatty Returns. There are so many issues I am having a tough time knowing what to leave out.

I will be reporting on the matters coming out of the IQPC seminar next week.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Congratulations

Congratulations Barack Obama!

What a wonderful Inauguration!

Monday, January 19, 2009

How will Investment Funds apply IFRS?

Do you know the issues related to how investment funds will be applying IFRS? It seems that this category will also include reporting on investment funds themselves held on behalf of pension plans. Pension Plans themselves will not be adopting IFRS and the Accounting Standards Board in Canada will be studying accounting issues regarding pension plans and making proposals in the next few months. In Canada we appear to be on track for the application of IFRS to investment funds. As always please stay tuned!

Deloitte has published an industry specific publication on investment funds. This is one of a series of industry specific publications. "IFRS for Pension Funds: More Than Just Accounting and Reporting" The 14 -page document covers a lot of potential differences between US GAAP and IFRS as well as other non-accounting considerations. Canadian readers should of course be careful in reading the document since the difference may be different - an alliteration to be sure!

Interestingly the publication notes that "The level of resistance to IFRS within the investment management industry appears to be stronger than other industries". This seems to be because of the "specialized" nature of the funds. Is resistance futile - it remains to be seen.

There is much sentiment that US GAAP in this industry is vastly superior to IFRS. Would lack of appropriate industry guidance in this industry lead to a deterioration in reporting on adoption of IFRS? The SEC Proposed Roadmap asks "is it appropriate to exclude investment companies and other regulated entities filing or furnishing reports with the Commission from the scope of (the) Roadmap?"

The discussion in the document is comprehensive and definitely worth reading if you have any connection with an investment fund. One issue that is raised is rules for consolidation of entities. In all likelihood there will be more entities consolidated under IFRS rules. Four pages - single-spaced of IFRS US GAAP issues are noted!

The document also suggests some useful matters for management and the Board of Directors to consider as they mull over their response to the possible coming of IFRS to American Investment Funds.

Clearly we will be watching this debate very closely in Canada.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Last call for Toronto Summit

There will be a Summit on IFRS for Canada on January 27 - 28, 2009. The two day event will deal with practical issues on IFRS and representatives from various companies will be speaking on a number of issues related to IFRS conversions. The organizations represented at the Summit include:
Accounting Standards Board Canada
International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC)
Microsoft Corporation
Bombardier Inc
AltaGas Ltd
The Finance Group
Canadian Financial Executives Research Foundation
Homes Trust Company
Hydro One
Axiotron
HEC Montreal
egX Group Inc.
The Kidney Foundation of Canada
Agrana Fruit US Inc
Canam International
Agrium Inc.
TD Bank Financial Group
Gildan Activewear Inc,

The session will deal with private company issues and small/medium size businesses as well as public company issues. The topics include "the usual suspects".

Project management for IFRS
IFRS1 Implementation issues
Property, Plant and Equipment
Mergers and Acquisitions
Fair Value Accounting

The presentations will be given by people with real life implementation experiences.

I (the IFRS Exorcist herself) will be giving a workshop on pension and other related areas . I will be covering IAS 19 Employee Benefits for the most part but I will also be talking about recent discussions on pension funds and pension plans. I will not be dealing with stock option plans. The session will be held post conference, on the second day of the event.

Although much has been said about current pension issues not a lot has been said about IFRS and pension issues for Canada. Perhaps I am walking in "where angels fear to tread?" Let's see!

I cannot overemphasize the need to look at your pensions issues now. Work with your actuary to develop a plan. Take your plans and analyze them under IFRS. Do not rely on trying to just find differences. You need to understand where the differences might be but you must take a fresh look. I will report on the meeting and issues that come out of it.

As a reader of this blog you are entitled to a discount. Please contact Kim Vigilia at to register for the best possible pricing. Please state that you are a reader of this blog.

IQPC || 535 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10017

Ph: 212-885-2753 || Fax: 888.231.7864 || kim.vigilia@iqpc.com

For details please go to the IQPC website.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Will the new SEC Chair derail IFRS plans?

Mary Schapiro has been nominated by Barack Obama to replace Christopher Cox as the new Chair of the SEC. The buzz in the financial and accounting press and the blogs is speculation on whether there will be a change on plans to adopt IFRS in the USA.
Back in November the SEC issued a proposed Roadmap for implementation of IFRS in the USA. Comments are due at the SEC next month. Essentially the Roadmap proposes a phased implementation of IFRS in the USA, starting in 2014. Certain companies who qualify under restricted criteria would be permitted to adopt IFRS early but would still be required to provide reports following US GAAP. It is further proposed that there would be a review by the SEC to confirm the decision to proceed based on some milestones, such as progress on standards, governance of the IASB and educational readiness among other matters. You may also be aware that the SEC eliminated the US GAAP reconciliation requirement for foreign issuers in 2007.

The SEC had announced a decision to proceed with the roadmap to SEC during the summer but there was a delay in issuance of the formal proposals which were eventually issued for comment after the US election and on the eve of the G20 meeting last November. The delay led to a lot of speculation whether there was a will to proceed in the current economic environment. Others suggested that the train has essentially left the station and this was evidenced by the active international cooperation on valuation and classification of financial instruments.
Ms. Schapiro is undergoing her confirmation process. She was reported to have said in response to a question regarding IFRS, she has concerns with the SEC’s current road map for transitioning U.S. public companies to IFRS.

“I will take a big deep breath and look at this entire area again carefully and will not necessarily feel bound by the existing road map that’s out for comment,” . See the report on the USA AICPA IFRS site

In CFO.com there was an article that Obama's supporters are at loggerheads on this issue. The article Top Obama Advisers Clash on Global Accounting Standards, by David Katz and Sarah

Johnson refers to reports that Obama's economic adviser Paul Volcker has expressed support for the IASB, at at recent press conference where he delivered a ringing endorsement of the establishment of International Financial Reporting Standards as part of a retooled regulatory system that he envisions.

It is early days yet in the Obama administration and indeed it does not officially start until Tuesday. One would expect a new SEC Chair to step back and take a big breath on a topic like the IFRS Roadmap. We have still to see the comments on the proposed roadmap. Let the due process take its course. As I have reported here there are supporters and detractors. In any event the IASB and FASB are working vigorously toward conformity of standards and this exercise will proceed. I am not American and I can only comment from the viewpoint of an interested observer. It's my view that it is far too early to draw conclusions about whether IFRS is coming to America from recent comments, As an interested observer I can only say that, in my personal view,not of any organization to which I belong, it would be very unfortunate if the USA dropped out or significantly delayed IFRS adoption. We cannot surely deny that we live in a global environment? The ongoing economic crisis is delivering the message load and clear. We must deal with issues on a global basis , including financial reporting. Yes it has its difficulties but who said it had to be easy!



Friday, January 16, 2009

Ten critical points for preparing your pre IFRS preconversion MD&A

This week the CICA put on a webinar in the pre-implementation communications under IFRS, as required by the CSA. The OSFI requires a similar set of dissimilar set of disclosures for federally regulated financial institutions. I posted about these requirements previously.


The webinar war presented by Peter Chant, a technical partner at Deloitte. He was one of the authors of the CCH publication iGAAP:IFRS for Canada If you did not listen to it when it was originally presented, it is archived and can be accessed here. (Please report any broken link). Some 1900 people had signed up for the presentation.

Chant emphasized that the conversion exercise really starts in the comparative period (January 1, 2010 for calendar year companies). I must confess that many do not seem to be showing a sense of urgency (see my post yesterday -there are of course a lot of other pressures right now). I have put a widget on this blog website with the now-famous White Rabbit, together with a count-down clock to January 1, 2010. Time is running very short and resources may not be readily available at the last minute.

What will be disclosed in the first crop of MD&A disclosures called for under the CSA rules? The CICA Corporate Performance Reporting Board published a very useful guidance document. You can read about it and get the link to the document at my previous post. Among other matters the document suggests the use of KPIs (key performance indicators) in explaining the impact of IFRS on the company - interesting! This document will also be useful for non-Canadian readers of this blog.

Some messages in the presentation:

1) There are going to be a lot of changes in IFRSs between now and reporting for the year end 2001. There may even be some consideration of early adoption of some standards. Clearly then a key component of any IFRS conversion will be to monitor key projects that affect your company. I spoke about this yesterday on this blog. All this instability provides a disincentive for early disclosure of preliminary impacts.

2) The current economic environment is, to say the least, unfavorable. Even though it will be critical for companies to approach lenders on the potential impact of IFRS adoption. There may even be a pressing need to renegotiate debt covenants. Do not wait until the last minute to renegotiate these.

3) A changeover should be broad based and one should consider not only the required changes to IFRS. One needs to consider any coincident other changes in accounting policies that are not necessarily required by IFRS.

4) There seems to be no benefit to a company to tip their hand prior to 2010 and even up to the very last minute. The exemptions under IFRS 1 need to be dealt with strategically. The volatility of the economic environment is not conducive for early decisions. Of course companies will do internal analysis but will not want to tip their hand too early.

5) Disclosure of potential accounting policy changes in MD&A will not necessarily lock companies into actual future use. However, it may be necessary to publish a comprehensive recap and analysis at the end of the first year of official reporting. This would show a reconciliation with previously reported potential changes - an aid for analysts.

6) Do not be too hasty in making any broad brush statements in you MD&A or other documents. Be careful for example in any statements about the effects of "cash" impacts. There may be tax impacts that you may not originally discover (one impact may be cash tax impacts - careful). Chant cautioned about cash reporting under IFRS - cash flow from operations may be affected. Try to explain that.

7) There is no standard format for the MD&A disclosures the CPRB report suggests a tabular disclosure for consistency and comparability.

8) Find some comparable IFRS reporting entities in your industry. However, be careful in interpreting the reported information (see my post on this matter).

9) Do not ignore IFRIC, the interpretation wing of IASB, in following IFRS and potential impacts on your company.

10) Make sure you have the appropriate IFRS competencies in your company and on your Audit Committee/Board.


Chant mentioned an interesting example in his presentation. Check out the 2005 Abbey National analysis they presented as a separate document on adoption of IFRS. (It was unaudited). A similar approach might be useful for your company too?

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Will the Canadian IFRS Conversion be deferred?

No deferral of the IFRS conversion date (for fiscal years beginning on or after January 1, 2011) is expected.


I have been speaking with a number of people about IFRS in Canada over the last week or so. A surprising number (perhaps) are asking whether the Canadian Accounting Standards Board plans a deferral of the conversion date. The answer is that there is no deferral and it is definitely not on the table for discussion.


The credit crisis has distracted many from the effort of converting to IFRS. It is quite difficult to concentrate on an exercise that seems to be two years away one one is concerned about meeting current commitments.


How prepared are publicly accountable enterprises? A survey by the CICA late last year indicated that the degree of preparedness has increased over 2008 but less than 50% had indicated their initial preparation for IFRS! Less than 4% of the companies surveyed by the CICA have appointed a project leader or team for IFRS. This is really surprising!


There is some anecdotal evidence that there has been some delay in IFRS projects. Many may not have gone much further than an initial diagnostic and some early stage training. We will see some information in the next few months as companies issue their MD&A for the December 31, 2008 year end under CSA requirements to disclose the progress toward IFRS conversion. The first voluntary results (discussed on the CICA webinar on the CSA MD&A requirements this week) seem to indicate that initial activity may have been minimal when compared with the large task ahead. However as the presenter, Dr. Chant from Deloitte, pointed out there may be a reluctance to disclose to much too early since it is simply too early to be too definitive. (I will give you some highlights from the CICA webinar and a link tomorrow - it was worth listening to).


Last year was a year of surprises. We knew about the credit crisis but we certainly did not call the extent of the market declines in the fall that caused a flurry of activity. Including the fair value discussion among accounting setters around the world. Commodity prices, especially oil, have come down dramatically. The Canadian Dollar declined by 20% or so. All these matters affect the psyche of accounting standards setters. We can expect more activities and indeed we have the right to actually demand more activity on critical issues such as fair value determination and impairments.


Another factor of some concern to some people is the activity at the IASB to conform with US accounting standards (the "Norwalk" agreement). The SEC's proposed IFRS roadmap sets out certain milestones and this has raised the ante somewhat.


Change is everywhere on the accounting horizon. Just take a look at the projects that are on the IASB's plate! To help us track these projects the AcSB has published a memorandum to help us understand the possible changes that may take place from now until 2011. We have not been provided with the same stability as the EU conversion a few years ago. It will be a critical part of everyone's conversion plan to monitor the IFRS changes that will be taking place and are pending over the next three years or so! Of course this will also be true for other countries (e.g Brazil and India) converting or converging with IFRS over the next few years.


According to Paul Cherry, the Chair of the Canadian Accounting Standards Board, there will be no deferral of the IFRS conversion date for Canadian Publicly Accountable Enterprises. Mr. Cherry was speaking at a Deloitte session last week on year end issues for Corporate Directors. We are still on track for 2011. We have still to hear the official positions about accounting rules going forward on private enterprises and not for profit entities from the AcSB. The word is that it will not be too much longer.


So it's not full speed ahead an d**n the torpedoes. It is go ahead expeditiously and watch for the icebergs ahead, you will need to keep a sharp look out for those changes.